The USPTO Handed IPR Decisions Back to the PTAB. The New Rules Are the Real Story.

A Nov. 10 USPTO memo returns the merits side of IPR and PGR institution to PTAB panels, and tells them how to decide.

·5 min read
Share

Since Monday, Nov. 16, three-judge PTAB panels again decide the merits side of whether an IPR or PGR gets started. For the past year, the Director made those calls himself.

Don’t read this as a return to the old days. The memo that made the change also tells panels how to decide, and the rules lean toward denial.

What changed

The Nov. 10 memo is addressed to the Board’s judges. It comes from Director John Squires, with General Counsel John Duffy concurring. It sets up two steps.

First, the Director screens each petition on grounds that don’t involve the merits, including discretionary ones. Petitions that pass go to a three-member panel, which decides institution on the merits on the Director’s behalf. If the panel institutes, a different panel runs the trial, and none of the institution judges can sit on it.

The change applies to every IPR and PGR that hasn’t yet been referred for merits review. The briefing process stays the same. The memo replaces the Director’s October 2025 order to the extent it kept all of these decisions in his office, and it says the Director keeps the power to grant or deny institution himself.

Panels will also explain their decisions. Each one should briefly cover the merits points the panel found important, with enough detail to show whether the petitioner met the standard for at least one claim and one ground. Panels don’t have to address every argument, and some decisions can be longer than others. The Director’s own non-merits calls can still come as a written opinion or a short summary notice.

Five rules for the panels

The memo says these guidelines are illustrative, not exhaustive:

  1. For any ground based on prior art, the petition must explain how the references disclose or suggest every limit of every challenged claim, and point to the exact parts relied on. Pointing to the examiner’s findings isn’t enough.
  2. If the petitioner falls short on a “substantial majority” of the challenged claims, the panel will deny institution.
  3. The panel will deny if the patent owner’s preliminary response makes a reasonable argument, backed by reliable, credible evidence, that the petitioner fell short on that majority.
  4. The panel will also deny if it reaches that conclusion on its own.
  5. When applying rules 2 to 4, if the arguments for and against a claim are about equal, the petitioner has not met the standard for that claim. In plain terms, a tie goes to the patent owner.

The memo adds that other situations can count against a petitioner too. One example it gives is an earlier ruling that claims of the same or a related patent are not invalid.

What the memo says about its own rules

The memo is open about one point: the statute only requires that at least one challenged claim meet the standard. It says denials under the “substantial majority” rule can fairly be called discretionary, but it treats them as tied to the merits and hands them to the panels.

It bases the approach on the statute’s minimum threshold, the Supreme Court’s SAS Institute decision (the Office must decide on the whole petition, all or nothing), and statements by Senator Jon Kyl during the AIA debate. It also compares the IPR standard to the one for preliminary injunctions, where a substantial question about validity is enough to defeat the request.

The memo does not say what “substantial majority” means. It cites earlier decisions for rule 2, including two informative Board decisions from 2018 and 2019 and a May 2026 Director decision. It also points judges to two recent Director decisions as models for writing institution decisions, one involving Merck Sharp & Dohme and one involving Samsung and Whirlpool.

Why now

The memo says data from the past 18 months shows petitioners have adapted since the Director’s Magnolia Medical v. Kurin decision in May. In June 2025, about 60% of petitions were denied on discretionary grounds. In September 2026, the Director denied 15% on those grounds and referred 85% for merits review.

It also says the Director decided more than 325 institution cases involving the merits over the past year, working closely with the judges, and it calls their work remarkable.

What our data shows

LexDana tracks how terminated IPRs ended. Denial of institution made up 16.76% of terminations in 2021 and 28.29% in 2022. It was 24.78% in 2023 and 26.66% in 2024. It rose to 45.45% in 2025 and stands at 45.78% so far in 2026. Over the same period, settlements fell from 41.58% to 14.12%.

Don’t line these up against the memo’s figures. The memo counts petitions the Director denied on discretionary grounds. LexDana counts how cases that ended in a given year were resolved. Cases that ended in 2026 were mostly filed earlier, so the two sets of numbers may describe different groups of petitions.

What to do now

Petitioners: Pick claims with care. A thin showing on dependent claims can now sink the whole petition. Give element-by-element detail for every claim you challenge, check for earlier rulings that upheld the claims, and don’t lean on the examiner’s findings.

Patent owners: The preliminary response matters more. Aim it at the whole petition, not just the main claim, and back it with reliable, credible evidence. In practice, that can include expert declarations.

What to watch

  • How panels define “substantial majority”
  • How often a tie decides a claim
  • Whether the written decisions give real detail
  • Whether denial rates move now that panels are making the merits call

Three takeaways

  1. Who decides the merits changed. The Director’s approach to deciding them didn’t.
  2. Claim count now matters. A petition is judged as a whole.
  3. Evidence at the institution stage counts for more than it did.

Sources: USPTO, “Returning Merits-Based Considerations to PTAB,” memorandum (Nov. 10, 2026); LexDana.

Found this useful? Share it with your team.

Need an expert for your matter?

Submit a case brief in 5 minutes. 2+ vetted candidates in 24–72 hours — no cost to search.

Request an Expert →